Topic: Violation

There are no members reading this topic.


This topic was closed by Takeko
  Posted on January 10, 2012 10:35 PM
#1
-Rukia, The Ambitious Priestess of the Hebi

Contribution: 1,715 (1,645 + 70)
Joined: November 22, 2010
Here's the deal:

If somebody violates the rule, in all likelihood their post(s) will be deleted. This is all very well but what if not? I mean, I've seen topics closed by a moderator yet none of the posts that I (and I'm well aware of what's considered flaming blablabla :P) took as flaming blablabla have been removed to this day. So, I was like: What???

So I would only like to ask you one question: Does every single offensive/etc. post get removed, or does it only happen in case they have been taken as flooding, etc.? Thank you :)
  Posted on January 10, 2012 10:44 PM
#2
Taylor, The Manipulative Tactician of the Darkness

Contribution: 978 (853 + 125)
Joined: February 19, 2010
-Rukia wrote:

Here's the deal:

If somebody violates the rule, in all likelihood their post(s) will be deleted. This is all very well but what if not? I mean, I've seen topics closed by a moderator yet none of the posts that I (and I'm well aware of what's considered flaming blablabla :P) took as flaming blablabla have been removed to this day. So, I was like: What???

So I would only like to ask you one question: Does every single offensive/etc. post get removed, or does it only happen in case they have been taken as flooding, etc.? Thank you :)


Actually, Rukia, as far as I perceive, there are several factors that decide whether a post will be deleted or not, but the most important one (as I perceive, again) is the following:

Does the post add anything onto the discussion?

If it breaches the rule, but does such by adding something to the discussion (e.g. - I write a post telling how your story sucks and how you should stop writing attacking you with harsh words, but give feedback on the work as well), then that person would get a warning, but not have his post deleted. In case the post add NOTHING to the situation in hand AND breaches the rule, those posts will be most likely deleted.

That's how I perceive the method to be.
2cfzf38.png
Lunar_Cry wrote:

The moment you think you know everything is the moment that you know nothing.


Taylor's Poem Showcase (Click it. Now.)
  Posted on January 10, 2012 10:48 PM
#3
-Rukia, The Ambitious Priestess of the Hebi

Contribution: 1,715 (1,645 + 70)
Joined: November 22, 2010
Thank you very much, Taylor. I just the same am awaiting a moderator to clear this up.
  Posted on January 10, 2012 10:50 PM
#4
Takeko, The Respected Swordsman of the Ancestors

Contribution: 1,347 (1,249 + 98)
Joined: November 24, 2010
Are you talking about when a post is like warned and then hidden? Or when it is completely removed from the topic. Two different things.
torndone.png
Mars BarsCaseStaff ID • Made by Faraz •
  Posted on January 11, 2012 6:34 AM
#5
Sakura-Chan-Ship, Prisoner

Contribution: 517 (435 + 82)
Joined: February 16, 2010
Takeko wrote:

Are you talking about when a post is like warned and then hidden? Or when it is completely removed from the topic. Two different things.

Sometimes it says: This post has been removed. So it doesn't show the content anymore. I think that is what Rukia is talking about.
  Posted on January 11, 2012 7:25 AM
#6
Takeko, The Respected Swordsman of the Ancestors

Contribution: 1,347 (1,249 + 98)
Joined: November 24, 2010
Lol. If that is the case, then Rukia asking a moderator secret. Which I do not know if I should reveal or not.

Based on what the infraction is, we can choose to delete it, hide it, or leave be. But it goes into more detail as to how warnings work and that is a secret I am not ready to reveal until a few changes happens. :amused

Sorry.
torndone.png
Mars BarsCaseStaff ID • Made by Faraz •