Topic: Clan Alliance
Users reading this topic: There are no members reading this topic.

This topic was closed by Hikaru
  • 1
  Posted on March 22, 2011 18:44
#1
-Rukia, The Manipulative Diva of the Hebi

Contribution: 1,664 (1,598 + 66)
Joined: November 22, 2010
I thought this ought to be implemented, unless it has already been,
but I am really not sure of that. With a view to understanding it, read
it properly, thoroughly. If not, go away, and your post does not make
sense.

So, there hasn't yet been an option which does the following: You are allied with Clan X, but you cannot do anything. Therefore, I thought this would be accepted: If you are allied with a clan, then you can put some clan members into the clan you're allied with. Of course,
the member who was put in to the other clan would receive a notification telling them they were put in to the clan you concluded an alliance with.
Inactive
You can find me on METIN2.

  Posted on March 22, 2011 18:53
#2
Tar-Of-The-Light, The Raging Swordsman of the Military

Contribution: 399 (373 + 25.5)
Joined: January 15, 2011
Ummm... you make a topic to answer a suggestion from Tsu??
tari.png
All sig credit goes to: DeadSight
ALL avy credit goes to: DeadSight

Graphics comes in many forms. What's bad in his eyes is probably the best in anothers. Everyone got diffrent tastes, so. - Quote by Aaron from Xat

  Posted on March 22, 2011 18:56
#3
-Rukia, The Manipulative Diva of the Hebi

Contribution: 1,664 (1,598 + 66)
Joined: November 22, 2010
Ok, I took a close look at his topic, and no, it does not tell what mine does.
Inactive
You can find me on METIN2.

  Posted on March 22, 2011 19:06
#4
-Je5u, Samurai of Ninja Arts

Contribution: 711 (678 + 33.4)
Joined: January 23, 2011
Why would leader put own member to other clan?
If nothing seems to go right,
turn left! :teethFinland

  Posted on March 22, 2011 19:14
#5
-Rukia, The Manipulative Diva of the Hebi

Contribution: 1,664 (1,598 + 66)
Joined: November 22, 2010
-Je5u wrote:
Why would leader put own member to other clan?
Because if they feel like doing so, they will do it. It wouldn't be a must. However, clan alliance is to support the clan you conclude an alliance with, so it'd be nice to have the option. With that being said, not only could the allies advertize each clan, but they would be able to put members into the clans, that's to say the number of supports would increase dramatically. Don't forget that clans are communities, as are these forums.

Example: I am allied with Clan "K". I have been given permission to
put members of my clan into the clan. After I put him into clan K, he receives a notification about that.
Inactive
You can find me on METIN2.

  Posted on March 22, 2011 19:39
#6
Encore, The Demonic Elite

Contribution: 1,166 (979 + 186.6)
Joined: February 16, 2010
Actually this has not been mentioned by tsu on his clan idea. So in this case i strongly agree with you, how ever instead of putting the clan member into the other clan, you can just change who he gets a win for, or does it get split 50/50. Would make more sense.
allanate wrote:
tsu already made a more upgraded form of this suggestion.

Wrong, he made the suggestion for a clan alliance section, if anything is more upgraded it is this one.
25kojub.png
What a hoe 'tis is.

  Posted on March 22, 2011 19:51
#7
allanate, Warbringer

Contribution: 837 (796 + 40.7)
Joined: February 17, 2010
tsu already made a more upgraded form of this suggestion.

  Posted on March 22, 2011 22:28
#8
Tsugaga, The Untouchable VIP of the Shogunate

Contribution: 3,399 (3,058 + 341)
Joined: February 22, 2010
There is one main reason why I disagree. Clans lose more xp when on a higher lvl, so they can cheat by putting their good members in a new clan and then giving their main clan all the xp, when they lose they lose very low amounts. Assuming this issue would be fixed I'll continue...

Alliances are always formed but would people really win battles for that allied clan? I just don't see that many clans switching there wins over to get xp for the alliance clan.

This could be ok but I don't think it will get much support. If it was to happen then I would integrate it with my suggestion, which I think most are familiar with(look at sig if not). When allianced with another clan you could help that clan if they have a hard time winning by sending the winning xp of up to 3 of your members to their clan. This has to have a safe side or bad side though. The xp lost has to be taken from both clans.


P.S. Glad to see you suggest something again, its been awhile :amused


  Posted on March 23, 2011 04:54
#9
sajevoni, The Worthy Commander of Ninja Arts

Contribution: 168 (161 + 6.6)
Joined: February 17, 2011
alliance is good if there are castle siege.. Here we battle head on head of the clans...
BD-Ras.png
"goodman"
"who never quits"

  Posted on March 23, 2011 06:14
#10
-Je5u, Samurai of Ninja Arts

Contribution: 711 (678 + 33.4)
Joined: January 23, 2011
-Rukia wrote:
(...)
Because if they feel like doing so, they will do it. It wouldn't be a must. However, clan alliance is to support the clan you conclude an alliance with, so it'd be nice to have the option. With that being said, not only could the allies advertize each clan, but they would be able to put members into the clans, that's to say the number of supports would increase dramatically. Don't forget that clans are communities, as are these forums.

Example: I am allied with Clan "K". I have been given permission to
put members of my clan into the clan. After I put him into clan K, he receives a notification about that.

Sounds pretty bad idea to me, so i'll have to disagree w/ ur suggestion
If nothing seems to go right,
turn left! :teethFinland

  Posted on March 23, 2011 16:03
#11
Hikaru, Professor

Contribution: 1,375 (1,239 + 136.3)
Joined: March 7, 2010
No. Why would you transfer your clan's members to another clan? It's just pointless. And technically you can get your members to leave your clan and join another to help it temporarily; this idea just complicates everything and would even be abusable.

Locked.

  • 1