Poll: Do you agree with the list?

42 vote(s) since September 2, 2011 5:58 PM

  • For the most part, yes. (10) (23.81%)
  • Change a couple of characters around. (16) (38.1%)
  • No, this tier list is opposite of what I thought. (6) (14.29%)
  • Very rough, and rarely hit some in proper tiers. (6) (14.29%)
  • Yes, I agree 90 - 100% (4) (9.52%)
 Topic: Roach's WoN Tier List.

There are no members reading this topic.


This topic was closed by Nori
  Posted on January 30, 2012 4:34 PM
#46
Roach, The Masked Samurai of the Red Dawn

Contribution: 993 (873 + 120)
Joined: February 17, 2010
Added Karasu to the B-tier. Keep in mind this is without his retarded GotW combo. If I were to consider ridiculous swaps in this tier list, he would be S++

Although with this in mind, I might start doing a 'side tier list' where I, in my opinion, appropriately place characters in tiers considering them as a swap character, and not so much as a stand alone character.

FOr example: Yuzuki as a stand alone character is not very good, imo. However, as a swap character, she very easily jumps to A-S tier.

I will be keeping this in mind and update a little later.
  Posted on January 31, 2012 10:27 AM
#47
Mirroga, The Twisted Alchemist

Contribution: 2,110 (1,914 + 196)
Joined: March 10, 2010
Roach wrote:

Added Karasu to the B-tier. Keep in mind this is without his retarded GotW combo. If I were to consider ridiculous swaps in this tier list, he would be S++

Although with this in mind, I might start doing a 'side tier list' where I, in my opinion, appropriately place characters in tiers considering them as a swap character, and not so much as a stand alone character.

FOr example: Yuzuki as a stand alone character is not very good, imo. However, as a swap character, she very easily jumps to A-S tier.

I will be keeping this in mind and update a little later.


I think it's a good idea if you have 2 different tier sections. One is as a stand-alone, the other as swappables.
TheJuHantoLandscape.jpg
  Posted on February 1, 2012 12:28 AM
#48
Roach, The Masked Samurai of the Red Dawn

Contribution: 993 (873 + 120)
Joined: February 17, 2010
Mirroga wrote:

(...)

I think it's a good idea if you have 2 different tier sections. One is as a stand-alone, the other as swappables.

I'm debating on how to go about with the 'swap tier list.'

Do I in parenthesis next to the character write (As a swap character, x Tier).

Or, do I construct an entirely different tier list under the original list?

I feel the latter is more acceptable considering some characters really do jump through the scales as swap characters.
  Posted on February 11, 2012 6:17 PM
#49
Nestec, Saint

Contribution: 689 (657 + 32)
Joined: January 31, 2011
I really loved your in-depth analysis on Jyouzu.

To be honest, I know this would take TONS of time, but I would like to see you do an individual analysis on every character in the game. Maybe like 1 per week or something, lol.

Spoiler

God, War of Ninja needs something like the Backroom in the Smash forums.